Between Orders and Heresy foregrounds the dynamic, creative, and diverse late medieval religious landscapes that flourished within the spaces of social and ecclesiastical structures.
This collection reconsiders the arguments put forward in Herbert Grundmann's monumental book, Religious Movements in the Middle Ages, and challenges his traditional interpretive binary, recognized as the shared origins of many medieval religious movements. The contributors explore the social relationships fostered between secular clergy members, including parish priests, local canons, and aristocratic confessors, and examine the ways in which laypeople inspired and engaged in devotion beyond religious orders.
Each essay in the volume considers a major theme in medieval religious history, such as the implementation of apostolic ideals, pastoral relationships, crusade connections, vernacular traditions, and reform. Organized to historicize and challenge the deeply embedded historiographical tendencies that have long distorted the complex dynamics of the late medieval world, Between Orders and Heresy the binary of orders and heresies.
'This is one of the strongest and most stimulating collections of essays I've ever read. The volume is thrilling, not only for its cohesiveness but also for its original insights and approaches, and illuminates important later medieval developments in women's religious expression and institutions.' - Maureen C. Miller, Professor of History, University of California, Berkeley
'This impressive volume represents an excellent gathering of medieval scholars. The essays, each quite distinct in focus, investigate individual instances of religious movements in medieval Europe, while also directly or indirectly assessing Grundmann's historical outlook as well as its cogency, or lack thereof, to account for the available evidence in current scholarship.' - John Van Engen, Andrew V. Tackes Professor Emeritus of Medieval History, University of Notre Dame
Table of Contents:
List of Illustrations
Preface
John Van Engen
1. Introduction: Religion and Religious Worlds in Between
Jennifer Kolpacoff Deane, University of Minnesota Morris, and Anne E. Lester, Johns Hopkins University
2. Herbert Grundmann: Confession and the "Religious Movements"
Letha Böhringer, Universität zu Köln
3. Francis of Assisi, the Vita Apostolica, and the Roman Church: Rethinking the Paradigms
Amanda Power, University of Oxford
4. Hypocrites! Critiques of Religious Movements and Criticism of the Church, 1050–1300
Sita Steckel, University of Münster
5. Crusading as a Religious Movement: Families, Community, and Lordship in a Vernacular Frame
Anne E. Lester, Johns Hopkins University
6. Coming Together as an Apostolic Act: Confraternalism as an Umbrella for Medieval Religious Movements
Neslihan Şenocak, Columbia University
7. Reassessing the Links between "The Women’s Religious Movement" and "The Origins of a Religious Literature in the Vernacular" in France
Sean L. Field, University of Vermont
8. "More Useful in the Salvation of Others": Beguines, Religio, and the Cura Mulierum at the Early Sorbonne
Tanya Stabler Miller, Loyola University, Chicago
9. Between Charity and Controversy: The Grey Sisters, Liminality, and the Religious Life
Alison More, College of New Rochelle
10. Women, Power, and Religious Dissent: Why Women Never became Heresiarchs
Janine Larmon Peterson, Maurist University
11. Navigating Saintly Circles: Margherita Colonna and the Women’s Religious Movement in Rome
Lezlie Knox, Marquette University
12. The "Clever Girls" of Prague: Beguines, Preachers, and Late Medieval Bohemian Religion
Jana Grollová
Bibliography
Index
