Critical Thinking is a comprehensive introduction to the essential skills of good reasoning, refined and updated through seven editions published over more than two decades. This concise edition offers a succinct presentation of the essential elements of reasoning that retains the rigor and sophistication of the original text. The authors provide a thorough treatment of such central topics as deductive and inductive reasoning, logical fallacies, how to recognize and avoid ambiguity, and how to distinguish what is relevant from what is not. A companion website provides a range of interesting supplements, including interactive review materials, supplemental readings, and writing tips.
Table of Contents:
Acknowledgments
Online Materials
PART ONE: INTRODUCTION
Chapter 1: Reasoning and Critical Thinking
- Reasoning
- The Concept of Logical Strength
- Truth, Logical Strength, and Soundness
- Critical Thinking Skills
- Critical Thinking and the Science of Logic
- Self-Test No. 1
- Questions for Discussion
PART TWO: MEANING
Chapter 2: Meaning and Definition
- The Complexity of Language
- The Meaning of Language
- The Reference Theory of Meaning
- The Idea Theory of Meaning
- Meaning as Use
- The Main Functions of Language
- Self-Test No. 2
- Questions for Discussion
- Definition
- The Purposes of Definition
- Reportive Definitions
- Stipulative Definitions
- Essentialist Definitions
- Methods of Definition
- Genus-Species Method
- Ostensive Method
- Synonym Method
- Operational Method
- Contextual Method
- Assessing Reportive Definitions
- Too Broad a Definition
- Too Narrow a Definition
- Too Broad and Too Narrow a Definition
- Circular Definition
- Obscure Definition
- Assessing Stipulative and Essentialist Definitions
- A Warning
- Self-Test No. 3
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 3: Clarifying Meaning
- The Principle of Charity
- Linguistic Ambiguity
- Ambiguity and Vagueness
- Referential Ambiguity
- Grammatical Ambiguity
- Use and Mention
- Self-Test No. 4
- Analytic, Contradictory, and Synthetic Statements
- Self-Test No. 5
- Descriptive and Evaluative Meaning
- Self-Test No. 6
- Necessary and Sufficient Conditions
- Self-Test No. 7
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 4: Reconstructing Arguments
- Reconstruction
- Missing Premises and Conclusions
- Self-Test No. 8
- Special Cases
- Reports of Arguments
- Explanations
- Self-Test No. 9
- The Structure of Arguments
- Simple Arguments
- T Arguments
- V Arguments
- Complex Arguments
- Self-Test No. 10
- Another Warning
- Questions for Discussion
PART THREE: ASSESSING ARGUMENTS
Chapter 5: Strategies for Assessing Arguments
- The Fallacies Approach
- The Criterial Approach
- The Three Criteria of a Sound Argument
- Seven Rules for Assessing Arguments
- Rule 1. Identify the Main Conclusion
- Rule 2. Identify the Premises
- Rule 3. Identify the Structure of the Argument
- Rule 4. Check the Acceptability of the Premises
- Rule 5. Check the Relevance of the Premises
- Rule 6. Check the Adequacy of the Premises
- Rule 7. Look for Counter-Arguments
Chapter 6: Assessing Truth-Claims
- Theories of Truth
- The Correspondence Theory
- The Coherence Theory
- The Pragmatic Theory
- Types of Truth-Claims
- Empirical Truth-Claims
- Non-Empirical Truth-Claims
- Acceptability
- Self-Test No. 11
- Questions for Discussion
- Assessing the Acceptability of Premises
- Some Particular Fallacies
- Begging the Question
- Inconsistency
- Equivocation
- False Dichotomy
- Self-Test No. 12
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 7: Assessing Relevance
- The Criterion of Relevance
- Recognizing Irrelevant Premises
- Appeals to Authority (1)
- Some Particular Fallacies
- Ad Hominem
- Tu Quoque
- Straw Man
- Self-Test No. 13
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 8: Assessing Adequacy
- The Criterion of Adequacy
- Appeals to Authority (2)
- Appeals to Anecdotal Evidence
- Appeals to Ignorance
- The Slippery Slope Fallacy
- Causal Fallacies
- Post Hoc
- Confusing Cause and Effect
- Common Cause
- Self-Test No. 14
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 9: Deductive Reasoning
- The Nature of Deductive Reasoning
- Truth-Functional Statements
- Formal Validity and Soundness
- Valid Argument Forms
- Formal Invalidity
- Self-Test No. 15
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 10: Inductive Reasoning
- The Nature of Inductive Reasoning
- Inductive Generalization
- Statistical Syllogism
- Induction by Confirmation
- Analogical Reasoning
- Self-Test No. 16
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 11: Arguing Back
- Explaining the Weakness
- Counter-Examples
- Absurd Examples
- Counter-Arguments
- Self-Test No. 17
- Questions for Discussion
Chapter 12: Irrational Techniques of Persuasion
- Loaded Terms
- Vague Terms
- Loaded Questions
- False Confidence
- Selectivity
- Misleading Statistics
- Humor
- Red Herring
- Guilt by Association
- Persuasive Redefinition
- Self-Test No. 18
- Questions for Discussion
Appendix: Answers to Self-Tests
Glossary
Index